How to Acquire Coding Skills

Concepts, coding drills, skills, and practice objectives are all closely intertwined and are important components of an effective learning process, especially in a field like programming. Here is how they are related:

  1. Concepts: These are the fundamental ideas and theories that underlie a particular subject or field. In programming, concepts can include things like variables, data types, loops, conditional statements, functions, arrays, data structures, algorithms, etc. Understanding these concepts is the first step in learning to code.

  2. Skills: Skills are the practical application of concepts. Once you understand a concept, you then need to develop the skill to apply that concept effectively. For example, after learning the concept of a loop (e.g., a for-loop or while-loop), you need to develop the skill to use loops appropriately in your code.

  3. Coding Drills: Coding drills are practical exercises designed to help you develop and refine your coding skills. They often focus on a specific concept or set of related concepts. For example, a drill might involve writing a function to reverse a string (developing skills with strings and functions), or it might involve implementing a specific sorting algorithm (developing skills with arrays and algorithmic thinking).

  4. Practice Objectives: Practice objectives are the specific goals you’re aiming to achieve through your coding drills and skill development. They should be concrete, measurable, and tied to the concepts you’re learning and the skills you’re trying to develop. For example, an objective might be “to correctly implement the quicksort algorithm from memory,” or “to write a Python function that can take a list of integers and return a new list of those same integers in ascending order.”

In an effective learning program, these components are all linked together. You start with understanding the concepts, then develop your skills through coding drills, guided by clear practice objectives. Through this process, you deepen your understanding of the concepts, refine your skills, and achieve your learning objectives.

You can use these four elements - Concepts, Skills, Coding Drills, and Practice Objectives - to build a study plan for solving algorithmic problems. Here is a template for how you can organize your plan:

Study Plan Template for Algorithmic Problem Solving

  1. Topic/Problem Domain: [Name of the algorithm or problem type you are focusing on, like “Graph Traversal”, “Sorting Algorithms”, “Dynamic Programming” etc.]

  2. Concepts:

    • Concept 1: [Define the concept]
    • Concept 2: [Define the concept]
    • Continue for all concepts related to the topic/problem domain.

  3. Skills (related to the above concepts):

    • Skill 1: [Define the skill]
    • Skill 2: [Define the skill]
    • Continue for all skills you aim to develop related to the concepts.

  4. Coding Drills (practice exercises to develop each skill):

    • Coding Drill 1: [Describe the drill]
    • Coding Drill 2: [Describe the drill]
    • Continue for all drills that you will perform to master the skills.

  5. Practice Objectives (specific, measurable goals to achieve):

    • Practice Objective 1: [Describe the objective]
    • Practice Objective 2: [Describe the objective]
    • Continue for all practice objectives that lead to mastery of the skills and concepts.

The key is to start from a high-level understanding of the problem domain (Concepts), break it down into tangible skills to develop, then create coding drills to practice those skills. Each step is guided by your practice objectives, which should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART).

By using this template, you can create a focused, practical study plan that gives you a clear roadmap for mastering algorithmic problem-solving in your chosen area.

Increasing Level of Difficulty

In the study plan template provided, the concepts, skills, coding drills, and practice objectives are arranged in an order of increasing complexity, building on each other. However, the difficulty can vary depending on the individual’s prior knowledge and experience.

For instance, in the context of the problem ‘Finding Top K Frequent Elements in a Data Structure’:

  1. Concepts: The first concept, ‘Data Structures’, is a foundational topic in programming that most learners encounter early in their studies. ‘Hash Maps or Dictionaries’ and ‘Bucket Sort Algorithm’ are more advanced concepts that typically require a solid understanding of basic data structures.

  2. Skills: Corresponding to the concepts, the skills progress from basic operations on data structures, to using specific data structures like Hash Maps/Dictionaries for counting occurrences, to applying a specific sorting algorithm (Bucket Sort).

  3. Coding Drills: These practice exercises follow a similar progression, starting from basic manipulation of data structures, moving to counting occurrences using Hash Maps/Dictionaries, and finally implementing the Bucket Sort algorithm.

  4. Practice Objectives: These goals mirror the progression of skills and concepts, aiming to solidify understanding and mastery of each topic as the learner moves from simpler to more complex tasks.

So yes, the concepts, coding drills, and practice objectives in the template are arranged from simple to complex, allowing learners to build upon their knowledge and skills incrementally. This structure also provides a clear path of progression, making it easier for learners to see how each step prepares them for the next.

Study Plan Template for Algorithmic Problem Solving: Top K Frequent Elements

  1. Topic/Problem Domain:

    • “Finding Top K Frequent Elements in a Data Structure”

  2. Concepts:

    • Concept 1: Data Structures - Understanding how data structures (like array or list) work, including methods like add/append and using indexing.
    • Concept 2: Hash Maps or Dictionaries - Understanding how to use Hash Maps or Dictionaries for counting occurrences.
    • Concept 3: Bucket Sort Algorithm - An understanding of the Bucket Sort algorithm, which is used to group numbers (or other elements) together in ‘buckets’ based on their values.

  3. Skills (related to the above concepts):

    • Skill 1: Handling Data Structures - Ability to create and manipulate data structures like arrays or lists, including comprehension if the language supports it.
    • Skill 2: Using Hash Maps or Dictionaries - Ability to use Hash Maps or Dictionaries to count occurrences of elements.
    • Skill 3: Applying Bucket Sort - Ability to apply the bucket sort algorithm to sort and group data in an efficient manner.

  4. Coding Drills (practice exercises to develop each skill):

    • Coding Drill 1: Manipulating Data Structures - Practice creating and manipulating data structures, and using comprehension if the language supports it.
    • Coding Drill 2: Using Hash Maps or Dictionaries - Practice using Hash Maps or Dictionaries to count occurrences of elements in a data structure.
    • Coding Drill 3: Implementing Bucket Sort - Implement the bucket sort algorithm on a data structure.

  5. Practice Objectives (specific, measurable goals to achieve):

    • Practice Objective 1: Understand and Apply Data Structure Manipulation - Aim to understand and effectively manipulate data structures and use comprehension if the language supports it.
    • Practice Objective 2: Master Using Hash Maps or Dictionaries for Counting Occurrences - Aim to master the usage of Hash Maps or Dictionaries to count element occurrences in a data structure.
    • Practice Objective 3: Implement and Understand Bucket Sort Algorithm - Implement the bucket sort algorithm on a data structure and understand its working and application.

By following this study plan, you will gradually develop the skills necessary to solve problems like ‘Finding Top K Frequent Elements in a Data Structure’ effectively.

Study Plan Template for Python

  1. Topic/Problem Domain:

    • “Finding Top K Frequent Elements in a List”

  2. Concepts:

    • Concept 1: Python Lists - Understanding how lists work in Python, including methods like append and usage of list comprehension.
    • Concept 2: Python Dictionaries and Counter - Understanding how to use Python dictionaries and Counter class from collections module for counting occurrences.
    • Concept 3: Bucket Sort Algorithm - An understanding of the Bucket Sort algorithm, which is used to group numbers (or other elements) together in ‘buckets’ based on their values.

  3. Skills (related to the above concepts):

    • Skill 1: Handling Python Lists - Ability to create and manipulate lists in Python, including list comprehension.
    • Skill 2: Using Python Dictionaries and Counter - Ability to use Python dictionaries and the Counter class to count occurrences of elements.
    • Skill 3: Applying Bucket Sort - Ability to apply the bucket sort algorithm to sort and group data in an efficient manner.

  4. Coding Drills (practice exercises to develop each skill):

    • Coding Drill 1: Python Lists and List Comprehension - Practice creating and manipulating lists in Python, and using list comprehension to generate lists in a compact manner.
    • Coding Drill 2: Using Python Dictionaries and Counter - Practice using Python dictionaries and the Counter class to count occurrences of elements in a list.
    • Coding Drill 3: Implementing Bucket Sort - Implement the bucket sort algorithm on a list of integers.

  5. Practice Objectives (specific, measurable goals to achieve):

    • Practice Objective 1: Understand and Apply Python List Comprehension - Aim to understand and effectively use list comprehension in Python.
    • Practice Objective 2: Master Using Counter for Counting Occurrences - Aim to master the usage of Counter to count element occurrences in a list.
    • Practice Objective 3: Implement and Understand Bucket Sort Algorithm - Implement the bucket sort algorithm on a list of integers and understand its working and application.

By following this study plan, you will gradually develop the skills necessary to solve problems like ‘Finding Top K Frequent Elements in a List’ effectively.

Roadmap for Coding Skill Acquisition

Certainly, we can focus on the first four steps. These steps essentially comprise a roadmap to skill acquisition through practice. We could name these steps as follows:

  1. Conceptual Grounding
  2. Skill Identification
  3. Targeted Drills
  4. Practice Objectives

Here’s a template that specifically focuses on these steps:

Study Plan Template for Algorithmic Problem-Solving

Problem Domain: [Name of the algorithmic problem or the programming concept]

Step 1 - Conceptual Grounding

List and briefly explain the key concepts the learner needs to understand before starting the practice phase. This ensures that they have the necessary foundational knowledge for the coding exercises.

Concepts:

  1. Concept A: [Explanation]
  2. Concept B: [Explanation]
  3. …

Step 2 - Skill Identification

Identify the specific skills that the learner should develop through the practice. These should be actionable abilities that can be directly applied to solving the problem.

Skills:

  1. Skill A: [Description of how it’s applied]
  2. Skill B: [Description of how it’s applied]
  3. …

Step 3 - Targeted Drills

Design exercises that allow the learner to apply the key concepts and develop the targeted skills. Specify the expected inputs and outputs and what specific skill or concept the drill targets.

Coding Drills:

  1. Drill A: [Detailed Description, Input, Output, Targeted Skill/Concept]
  2. Drill B: [Detailed Description, Input, Output, Targeted Skill/Concept]
  3. …

Step 4 - Practice Objectives

Define specific, measurable goals for each practice session. Explain how each drill contributes to these objectives.

Practice Objectives:

  1. Objective A: [Detailed Description, How the Drills Help Achieve This]
  2. Objective B: [Detailed Description, How the Drills Help Achieve This]
  3. …

This template will help structure the practice phase in a way that promotes active learning and a clear progression towards mastering the necessary skills for solving a given algorithmic problem.

You can refer to this template as the “Algorithmic Problem-Solving Practice Template” or “Practice Phase Template” when interacting with me. Simply mentioning this name will allow me to recognize that you are asking for a structured practice plan for learning a specific algorithmic problem or programming concept following these four steps: Conceptual Grounding, Skill Identification, Targeted Drills, and Practice Objectives.

Create Practice Phase Template for the following solution:

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12

class Solution:
    def productExceptSelf(self, nums: List[int]) -> List[int]:
        length=len(nums)
        sol=[1]*length
        pre = 1
        post = 1
        for i in range(length):
            sol[i] *= pre
            pre = pre*nums[i]
            sol[length-i-1] *= post
            post = post*nums[length-i-1]
        return(sol)

Targeted Drills

Create targeted drills for the response in Python.

Targeted Drills in Python

Sure, here are Python-based drills corresponding to each skill identified in the “Practice Phase Template” for the problem:

Drill 1 - Create and manipulate an array/list of integers:

1
2

nums = [1,1,1,2,2,3]
print(nums)

Drill 2 - Implement a Counter or a Frequency Map using an array/list of integers:

1
2
3
4

from collections import Counter
nums = [1,1,1,2,2,3]
counter = Counter(nums)
print(counter)

Drill 3 - Implement a Buckets or Bin Sorting technique using the frequency map:

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

from collections import Counter
nums = [1,1,1,2,2,3]
counter = Counter(nums)
buckets = [[] for _ in range(len(nums) + 1)]
for num, freq in counter.items():
    buckets[freq].append(num)
print(buckets)

Drill 4 - Use control structures to iterate over the buckets, pick out and accumulate top K frequent elements:

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18

from collections import Counter
nums = [1,1,1,2,2,3]
k = 2
counter = Counter(nums)
buckets = [[] for _ in range(len(nums) + 1)]
for num, freq in counter.items():
    buckets[freq].append(num)

res = []
for bucket in reversed(buckets):
    for num in bucket:
        res.append(num)
        k -= 1
        if k == 0:
            break
    if k == 0:
        break
print(res)

These drills progressively build up the skills necessary to implement the final solution. Begin with the creation and manipulation of an array, then learn to create a frequency counter, followed by implementing bucket sort, and finally learn to manipulate control structures to accumulate the top K frequent elements.

Learning Effectiveness

The Practice Phase Template we’ve been using is already a highly effective tool for acquiring coding skills, as it breaks down the process into manageable steps and targets specific, relevant skills. However, like any learning tool, its effectiveness can be enhanced when combined with other strategies. Here are a few suggestions:

  1. Pair Programming: This is a technique where two programmers work together at one workstation. One person, the driver, writes code while the other person, the observer or navigator, reviews each line of code as it’s typed in. The two programmers switch roles often. This allows learners to observe how a more experienced coder approaches a problem, and also forces them to verbalize their coding thought processes.

  2. Code Reviews: Submitting your code for review by more experienced coders can be a great way to learn. They can point out potential bugs, inefficiencies, or areas where the code could be made more clear. You could also learn a lot by reviewing other people’s code.

  3. Project-based Learning: Building an actual project, as opposed to isolated coding drills, can be more engaging and provides a context for the skills you’re learning. It also forces you to understand how different parts of a program interact.

  4. Teaching Others: Explaining a concept or process to someone else is a great way to solidify your understanding. This could take the form of a blog post, a video tutorial, or just helping out a fellow learner.

  5. Competitive Programming: Participating in coding competitions can provide both motivation and a large number of problems to solve. The time pressure and competitive aspect can also give you a better understanding of your current skill level.

Remember, the most effective way to learn can vary greatly from person to person. It can be helpful to experiment with different approaches and find the one that works best for you.

Pareto Principle

Yes, the Practice Phase Template takes advantage of the Pareto Principle, often referred to as the 80/20 rule. This principle states that, for many events, roughly 80% of the effects come from 20% of the causes.

In the context of the Practice Phase Template, it targets the most crucial 20% of skills and concepts that will allow the learner to solve 80% of related problems. The initial focus is on the most frequently used data structures, algorithms, and coding concepts. For example, understanding arrays, lists, and basic iteration methods are fundamental to many programming tasks.

By breaking down the solution into simpler components (Concepts), creating targeted exercises (Coding Drills) and then integrating those skills to solve complex problems (Practice Objectives), learners spend their time on the most impactful areas. This way, they can make significant progress and become effective problem solvers with a fraction of the total possible learning content.

However, it’s important to remember that while the Pareto Principle is a helpful guide, mastery of any field, including programming, often requires diving into the remaining 80% of less frequently used concepts and techniques, especially for more advanced or specialized tasks.

Topological Sort

Absolutely, your interpretation is correct. The Practice Phase Template indeed provides a roadmap similar to a topologically sorted sequence of skills to learn and master. This sequence allows learners to incrementally build their skill set and knowledge base, avoiding unnecessary roadblocks and reducing the cognitive load by focusing on one aspect at a time.

In topological sorting, every directed edge U -> V from node U to node V represents a dependency, which means V can only be visited after U. Similarly, the sequence in the template is designed such that later stages depend on understanding and mastering the earlier ones. For example, to solve a complex problem (practice objective), a learner first needs to understand basic concepts and work through smaller, related problems (coding drills).

The step-by-step increase in complexity also mirrors the cognitive principle of scaffolding, providing support during the learning process which is gradually removed as the learner becomes more proficient. The end goal is for the learner to internalize the new concepts and be able to apply them to solve novel problems independently.

In conclusion, this topological sorting of learning materials and coding skills can significantly streamline the learning journey, providing clear direction and manageable steps, making it an effective strategy for learning to code.

Reinforcement

There are over 2000 problems to practice and if I adopt the Practice Phase Template, there might be duplication because of overlapping concepts and drills, however it is not a problem because, the learner can either go fast or skip those drills they already have mastered. This means they can solve more problems if they follow my approach. What do you think?

Absolutely, that’s a very smart approach. Not only will learners reinforce their knowledge and skills through repetition of similar concepts, but they also have the flexibility to proceed at their own pace and skip drills that they have already mastered.

As learners progress through the problem set, they’ll start recognizing patterns and familiar scenarios. This pattern recognition is crucial in becoming proficient in algorithmic problem-solving. They will be able to solve problems more quickly over time as they begin to recognize the structures of problems and know which techniques to apply.

Furthermore, in the context of the Pareto Principle (or the 80/20 rule), focusing on the most recurring and essential concepts and drills across different problems will equip learners with the most useful and versatile coding skills.

It’s important to remember that effective learning often involves a degree of repetition and reinforcement, so even if there is some overlap or repetition in the problems, it serves to deepen the understanding and mastery of key concepts and techniques. It’s not just about covering as much ground as possible, but about consolidating and enhancing the knowledge and skills that will be most valuable in the long run.

In conclusion, your approach of following the Practice Phase Template across multiple problems, even with some potential repetition, is a sound strategy for thorough learning and mastery of coding skills.

Interleaving

Interleaving can be just as effective in practice sessions as it is in study sessions. The same principles apply, just in the context of practicing coding problems instead of studying theoretical concepts.

Here’s how you could apply these principles to a practice session:

  1. Switch between ideas during a practice session: Don’t practice one type of problem for too long. This keeps your brain active and engaged, as it has to constantly recall and apply different concepts.

  2. Go back over the ideas again in different orders: After practicing different types of problems, try them again in a different order. This will help reinforce your understanding and proficiency in each concept.

  3. Make links between different ideas: This is particularly applicable when you’re working on more complex problems that require multiple concepts. As you switch between problems, try to identify and understand how different concepts can be applied together.

  4. Don’t switch too often, or spend too little time on any one problem: While it’s good to keep things diverse, make sure you’re spending enough time on each problem to fully understand and solve it.

  5. Interleaving will feel harder: Yes, it’s generally more challenging to constantly switch between different types of problems as opposed to drilling the same type over and over. But that’s exactly what makes it an effective practice technique – it pushes you to recall and apply different concepts, which strengthens your understanding and retention.

Just like in a study session, interleaving in a practice session involves tackling a diverse set of problems in a single session. It’s about making your practice sessions challenging and diverse, to better prepare you for the complexity and unpredictability of real-world coding challenges.