Increasing Decreasing String

First, we count the frequency of each character in s. Then we iterate through the sorted list of characters from both smallest to largest and largest to smallest, until all characters are used.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19

class Solution:
    def sortString(self, s: str) -> str:
        from collections import Counter

        # count the frequency of each character
        count = Counter(s)
        # get a sorted list of unique characters
        chars = sorted(count)
        result = []

        while len(result) < len(s):
            # iterate over the characters in ascending and descending order
            for charList in [chars, chars[::-1]]:
                for c in charList:
                    if count[c] > 0:
                        result.append(c)
                        count[c] -= 1

        return "".join(result)

This code first counts the frequency of each character using the collections.Counter method, which creates a dictionary with characters as keys and their counts as values.

It then creates a sorted list of unique characters in the string.

The main loop continues until the length of the result list equals the length of the input string s. For each iteration, it iterates over the list of unique characters in ascending and then in descending order, and if there are still occurrences of the current character left (i.e., count[c] > 0), it appends the character to the result list and decreases the counter.

Finally, it joins the result list into a string and returns it.

Q&A

Just find frequency of each character and do what the problem statement asks

Sure, let’s implement a solution according to the hint. The approach will be to maintain a frequency count of each character in the string. We then perform the operations as mentioned in the problem statement until all characters are consumed.

Here’s how you can do it in Python:

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

class Solution:
    def sortString(self, s: str) -> str:
        from collections import Counter

        # Count frequency of each character
        freq = Counter(s)

        # Create a list to store the result
        result = []

        while freq:
            # Iterate over sorted characters
            for ch in sorted(freq):
                result.append(ch)
                freq[ch] -= 1
                if freq[ch] == 0:
                    del freq[ch]
                    
            # Iterate over sorted characters in reverse
            for ch in sorted(freq, reverse=True):
                result.append(ch)
                freq[ch] -= 1
                if freq[ch] == 0:
                    del freq[ch]

        # Join the list into a string and return
        return ''.join(result)

In this solution, we first count the frequency of each character in the string s using the Counter from collections module. This gives us a dictionary where keys are characters and values are their frequencies.

Then, we loop until the freq dictionary is empty. In each iteration, we first iterate over the characters sorted in ascending order, append them to the result and decrease their count in the dictionary. If a character’s count reaches zero, we remove it from the dictionary. After that, we do the same for characters sorted in descending order.

Finally, we join the characters in the result list into a string and return it. This string is the result of sorting s using the given algorithm.

I am curious whether there can be an in-place (O(1)) algorithm for this

The algorithm to sort a string as described in the problem doesn’t lend itself to an in-place solution. The constraints of the problem, where we need to find the smallest and largest characters, almost inevitably involve a sorting operation, which can’t be done in constant space for arbitrary inputs.

An in-place algorithm doesn’t use any extra space and only a constant amount of extra space is allowed for variables. The process of sorting usually requires extra space for comparison and movement of elements.

Moreover, strings in Python are immutable, so any operation that modifies a string effectively creates a new one. So, technically speaking, it’s not possible to have an in-place algorithm that sorts a string in Python.

However, if the input was a list of characters instead of a string, and if we had a constraint on the range of these characters (for instance, if they were all lowercase English letters), we could potentially devise an in-place algorithm that would use a variant of counting sort. But that algorithm wouldn’t be able to solve this problem, because this problem requires us to create a new string that is not just a sorted version of the original string, but a string created by a specific set of rules.